Skip to content
All guides

Resale and repair

Restock, repair or write off? A per-item cost formula for returned garments

Value every route a returned item could take: price times the share recovered at its grade, minus fees and handling. Pick the highest. A worked example.

13 November 2026 · 4 min read · Taimoor ul Hassan, founder, WeaveCycle

For each returned item, work out the net value of every route it could take, then pick the highest. The net value of a route is the item's price, times the share of that price you expect to recover at the item's grade, minus fees, minus the cost of the work the route needs. If every route comes out below zero, the cheapest lawful exit wins. It takes a few inputs per route, and you only set them once.

The formula

For each route (restock, resale, repair, refurbish, recycle):

route value = item price × recovery share at this grade × (1 − fee share) + fixed value − handling cost

  • Item price: what the item sold for on the order line.
  • Recovery share at this grade: the share of that price the route typically brings back for an A, B or C item. Restocking an A item might recover most of its price. Reselling a B item at a discount recovers less. Restocking a C item recovers nothing, because it cannot be restocked.
  • Fee share: marketplace commission, payment fees or a partner's cut.
  • Fixed value: a flat amount per item, for example what a textile sorter pays.
  • Handling cost: the labour, materials and shipping that route needs: steaming and rebagging for a restock, photos and listing for a resale, the repair itself, outbound freight.

Pick the route with the highest value. If none is positive, choose the least negative route your policy and the law allow.

A worked example

A dress sold for 80, graded B (light marks, tags missing). With some illustrative inputs:

Route Recovery at B Fees Handling Value
Restock 0 (not new) 2 −2
Resale 40 of every 100 15 of every 100 5 80 × 0.40 × 0.85 − 5 = 22.20
Repair 0 at B 12 −12
Recycle fixed 0.50 1.50 −1.00

Resale wins. The same dress graded A would go to restock; graded C, repair might win if its recovery share at C is high enough.

These figures are starting estimates, not market data. Replace them with your own.

Which costs should you time?

Time each step on a sample of returns for a week, then apply your hourly rate:

  • Receiving: open, match to the order, confirm the SKU.
  • Inspection: visual check, smell, grade, defect code, photo if needed.
  • Repair: labour and materials, per repair type.
  • Repackaging and relabelling: kit cost plus time.
  • Listing: photos and description for resale.
  • Outbound: shipping to the buyer, outlet or recycler.
  • Waiting: days in holding times your storage cost, if it is material.

Published estimates put the cost of processing one return at $10 to $65, depending on category and process. Use your own timed figure; the range is only a sanity check.

Rules of thumb that follow from the formula

  • Do not repair when the repair plus handling is more than the uplift in value.
  • Prefer fast routes for seasonal stock. A lower value today can beat a higher one after the season ends.
  • Repair only with parts in stock and within your repair time limit; escalate anything else.
  • Check write-offs against the law. If you are a large company selling in the EU, destroying unsold clothing is allowed only in listed cases, returns count as unsold, and recycling can count as destruction. "The brand does not want it resold" is not one of the listed cases. See the EU ban on destroying returned clothes.

When the formula does not apply

  • Warranty and fault claims: resolve the claim before routing.
  • Unsafe or contaminated items: quarantine; do not repair or resell.
  • Counterfeits: hold and document.

Review it

Review the recovery shares and handling costs monthly against what routes actually brought in. Log when your team overrides the best route and why: those overrides are how you tune the numbers. For the bigger picture, see what a returned garment actually costs and how to decide between restock, resell, repair and write-off.

The formula in WeaveCycle

This is how WeaveCycle values routes. You set the recovery share by grade, fees, fixed value and cost per route in your return policy; WeaveCycle applies them to each returned item, shows every route's value and the arithmetic, and recommends the highest. Until you enter your own figures, the defaults are labelled starting estimates. See how it works.

Related reading

WeaveCycle checks return photos before the package is back and gives every returned item a route your policy allows. See how it works.

Early access

Run this workflow on your own returns.

Starter is free with 10 returns a month, each with a photo check.

Install free on Shopify

Early access: we're recruiting pilot brands.

Ask a question first

Analytics choice

We use PostHog analytics to understand how the public site is used, only if you accept. Sign-in still works if you decline. Read the Privacy Policy.